Literature (Narrative) Review

Toward Applicable EEG-Based Drowsiness Detection Systems: A Review

Abstract

Purpose: Drowsy driving accounts for many accidents and has attracted substantial research attention in recent years. Electroencephalography (EEG) signals are shown to be a reliable measure for the early detection of drowsiness. Unfortunately, there is no comprehensive study showing the applicability of drowsiness detection systems with EEG signals. In this research, we targeted the studies under the category of drowsiness detection, which adopted an EEG-based approach, to inspect the applicability of these systems from different aspects.

Materials and Methods: We included documented studies that utilized clinical devices and consumer-grade EEG headsets for detection of drowsiness and investigated the selected studies from different aspects such as the number of EEG channels, sampling frequency, extracted features, type of classifiers, and accuracy of detection. Among available headsets, we focused on the most popular ones, namely Muse, NeuroSky, and EMOTIV brands.

Results: Considerable number of studies have used EEG headsets, and their reports showed that the highest average accuracy belongs to EMOTIV, and the highest maximum detection accuracy, 98.8%, was achieved by the Muse headset. Spectral features extracted from short periods of 1, 2, or 10 secs are the most popular features, and the support vector machine is the most commonly used classifier in drowsiness detection systems. Therefore, implementing a reliable detection system does not necessarily include complicated features and classifiers.

Conclusion: It is shown that, despite their few electrodes, commercial headsets have gained decent detection accuracy. This study sheds light on the current status of drowsiness detection systems and paves the way for future industrial designs of such systems.

1- M. Zhu et al., "Heavy Truck Driver's Drowsiness Detection Method Using Wearable EEG Based on Convolution Neural Network." in 2020 IEEE Intelligent Vehicles Symposium (IV), (2020), pp. 195-201.
2- Masoud Ghasemi Noghabi, Saber Nasser Alavi Seyed, and Mahdieh Ghasemi Noghabi, "Statistical report of accidents caused by fatigue and drowsiness of vehicle drivers using police report at the scene of the accident." in The first national conference on traffic, safety and executive strategies to improve it, ed, (2010).
3- Aleksandar Čolić, Oge Marques, and Borko Furht, "Driver drowsiness detection: Systems and solutions." (2014).
4- Albert Kircher, Marcus Uddman, and Jesper Sandin, "Vehicle control and drowsiness." (2002).
5- Bagus G. Pratama, Igi Ardiyanto, and Teguh B. Adji, "A review on driver drowsiness based on image, bio-signal, and driver behavior." Proceeding - 2017 3rd International Conference on Science and Technology-Computer, ICST 2017, pp. 70-75, (2017).
6- L M Bergasa, J Nuevo, M A Sotelo, R Barea, and M E Lopez, "Real-Time System for Monitoring Driver Vigilance." Trans. Intell. Transport. Sys., Vol. 7pp. 63-77, (2006).
7- Masoumeh Tashakori, Ali Nahvi, and Serajeddin Ebrahimian, "Driver drowsiness detection using facial thermal imaging in a driving simulator." Journal of engineering in medicine, pp. 1-13, (2021).
8- Serajeddin Ebrahimian Hadi Kiashari, Ali Nahvi, Amirhossein Homayounfard, and Hamidreza Bakhoda, "Monitoring the Variation in Driver Respiration Rate from Wakefulness to Drowsiness: A Non-Intrusive Method for Drowsiness Detection Using Thermal Imaging." Journal of Sleep Sciences, Vol. 3pp. 1-9, (2018).
9- Serajeddin Ebrahimian Hadi Kiashari, Ali Nahvi, Hamidreza Bakhoda, Amirhossein Homayounfard, and Masoumeh Tashakori, "Evaluation of driver drowsiness using respiration analysis by thermal imaging on a driving simulator." Multimedia Tools and Applications, Vol. 79pp. 17793-815, (2020).
10- Masoumeh Tashakori, Ali Nahvi, Azadeh Shahiidian, Serajeddin Ebrahimian Hadi Kiashari, and Hamidreza Bakhoda, "Estimation of driver drowsiness using blood perfusion analysis of facial thermal images in a driving simulator." Journal of Sleep Sciences, Vol. 3pp. 45-52, (2018).
11- Rami N Khushaba, Sarath Kodagoda, Sara Lal, and Gamini Dissanayake, "Driver Drowsiness Classification Using Fuzzy Wavelet-Packet-Based Feature-Extraction Algorithm." IEEE Transactions on Biomedical Engineering, Vol. 58pp. 121-31, (2011).
12- Arun Sahayadhas, Kenneth Sundaraj, and Murugappan Murugappan, "Detecting driver drowsiness based on sensors: A review." Sensors (Switzerland), Vol. 12pp. 16937-53, (2012).
13- Shubha Majumder, Bijay Guragain, Chunwu Wang, and Nicholas Wilson, "On-board drowsiness detection using EEG: Current status and future prospects." IEEE International Conference on Electro Information Technology, Vol. 2019-Maypp. 483-90, (2019).
14- Saroj K L Lal and Ashley Craig, "Driver fatigue: electroencephalography and psychological assessment." (in eng), Psychophysiology, Vol. 39pp. 313-21, (2002).
15- Chin-Teng Lin et al., "Wireless and Wearable EEG System for Evaluating Driver Vigilance." IEEE Transactions on Biomedical Circuits and Systems, Vol. 8pp. 165-76, (2014).
16- Wei Li, Qi Chang He, Xiu Min Fan, and Zhi Min Fei, "Evaluation of driver fatigue on two channels of EEG data." Neuroscience Letters, Vol. 506pp. 235-39, (2012).
17- Boon-Giin Lee and Wan-Young Chung, "Multi-classifier for highly reliable driver drowsiness detection in Android platform." Biomedical Engineering: Applications, Basis and Communications, Vol. 24pp. 147-54, (2012).
18- Sarah N Wyckoff, Leslie H Sherlin, Noel Larson Ford, and Dale Dalke, "Validation of a wireless dry electrode system for electroencephalography." Journal of neuroengineering and rehabilitation, Vol. 12pp. 1-9, (2015).
19- Héctor Rieiro et al., "Validation of electroencephalographic recordings obtained with a consumer-grade, single dry electrode, low-cost device: A comparative study." Sensors, Vol. 19p. 2808, (2019).
20- Elena Ratti, Shani Waninger, Chris Berka, Giulio Ruffini, and Ajay Verma, "Comparison of medical and consumer wireless EEG systems for use in clinical trials." Frontiers in Human Neuroscience, Vol. 11pp. 1-7, (2017).
21- Hyun Jae Baek, Gih Sung Chung, Ko Keun Kim, and Kwang Suk Park, "A smart health monitoring chair for nonintrusive measurement of biological signals." IEEE transactions on Information Technology in Biomedicine, Vol. 16pp. 150-58, (2011).
22- Joan Gomez-Clapers and Ramon Casanella, "A fast and easy-to-use ECG acquisition and heart rate monitoring system using a wireless steering wheel." IEEE Sensors Journal, Vol. 12pp. 610-16, (2011).
23- Dong Qian et al., "Drowsiness Detection by Bayesian-Copula Discriminant Classifier Based on EEG Signals During Daytime Short Nap." IEEE Transactions on Biomedical Engineering, Vol. 64pp. 743-54, (2017).
24- Jonathan R L Schwartz and Thomas Roth, "Neurophysiology of sleep and wakefulness: basic science and clinical implications." (in eng), Current neuropharmacology, Vol. 6pp. 367-78, (2008).
25- Ritchie E Brown, Radhika Basheer, James T McKenna, Robert E Strecker, and Robert W McCarley, "Control of sleep and wakefulness." (in eng), Physiological reviews, Vol. 92pp. 1087-187, (2012).
26- Sónia Soares, Tiago Monteiro, António Lobo, António Couto, Liliana Cunha, and Sara Ferreira, "Analyzing driver drowsiness: From causes to effects." Sustainability, Vol. 12p. 1971, (2020).
27- Ronald E Dahl, "Biological, developmental, and neurobehavioral factors relevant to adolescent driving risks." American journal of preventive medicine, Vol. 35pp. S278-S84, (2008).
28- Roseanne Armitage, "Sex differences in slow-wave activity in response to sleep deprivation." Sleep Res Online, Vol. 4pp. 33-41, (2001).
29- Carina Fors, Christer Ahlstrom, and Anna Anund, "A comparison of driver sleepiness in the simulator and on the real road." Journal of Transportation Safety & Security, Vol. 10pp. 72-87, (2018).
30- Riccardo Rossia, Massimiliano Gastaldia, and Gregorio Gecchelea, "Analysis of driver task-related fatigue using driving simulator experiments." Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences, Vol. 20pp. 666-75, (2011).
31- A I Pack, A M Pack, E Rodgman, A Cucchiara, D F Dinges, and C W Schwab, "Characteristics of crashes attributed to the driver having fallen asleep." (in eng), Accident; analysis and prevention, Vol. 27pp. 769-75, (1995).
32- Zhongke Gao et al., "Relative Wavelet Entropy Complex Network for Improving EEG-Based Fatigue Driving Classification." IEEE Transactions on Instrumentation and Measurement, Vol. 68pp. 2491-97, (2019).
33- Chun Shu Wei, Yu Te Wang, Chin Teng Lin, and Tzyy Ping Jung, "Toward Drowsiness Detection Using Non-hair-Bearing EEG-Based Brain-Computer Interfaces." IEEE Transactions on Neural Systems and Rehabilitation Engineering, Vol. 26pp. 400-06, (2018).
34- Jongseong Gwak, Akinari Hirao, and Motoki Shino, "An investigation of early detection of driver drowsiness using ensemble machine learning based on hybrid sensing." Applied Sciences (Switzerland), Vol. 10(2020).
35- John LaRocco, Minh Dong Le, and Dong Guk Paeng, "A Systemic Review of Available Low-Cost EEG Headsets Used for Drowsiness Detection." Frontiers in Neuroinformatics, Vol. 14pp. 1-14, (2020).
36- Anna Wexler and Robert Thibault, "Mind-Reading or Misleading? Assessing Direct-to-Consumer Electroencephalography (EEG) Devices Marketed for Wellness and Their Ethical and Regulatory Implications." Journal of Cognitive Enhancement, Vol. 3pp. 131-37, (2019).
37- Ali Hashemi et al., "Characterizing population EEG dynamics throughout adulthood." ENeuro, Vol. 3(2016).
38- Olave E Krigolson, Chad C Williams, Angela Norton, Cameron D Hassall, and Francisco L Colino, "Choosing MUSE: Validation of a low-cost, portable EEG system for ERP research." Frontiers in neuroscience, Vol. 11p. 109, (2017).
39- Azmeh Shahid, Kate Wilkinson, Shai Marcu, and Colin M Shapiro, "Stanford Sleepiness Scale (SSS) BT - STOP, THAT and One Hundred Other Sleep Scales." Azmeh Shahid, Kate Wilkinson, Shai Marcu, and Colin M Shapiro, Eds., ed. New York: Springer New York, (2012), pp. 369-70.
40- Asha Hareendran, Nancy K. Leidy, Brigitta U. Monz, Randall Winnette, Karin Becker, and Donald A. Mahler, "Proposing a standardized method for evaluating patient report of the intensity of dyspnea during exercise testing in COPD." International journal of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, Vol. 7pp. 345-55, (2012).
41- Douglas M Wiegand, J. McClafferty, Sharon E. McDonald, and Richard J Hanowski, "Development and evaluation of a naturalistic Observer Rating of Drowsiness protocol." Vtechworks.Lib.Vt.Edu, pp. 1-52, (2009).
42- Walter W. Wierwille and Lynne A. Ellsworth, "Evaluation of driver drowsiness by trained raters." Accident Analysis and Prevention, Vol. 26pp. 571-81, (1994).
43- Eric Juwei Cheng, Ku Young Young, and Chin Teng Lin, "Temporal EEG imaging for drowsy driving prediction." Applied Sciences (Switzerland), Vol. 9(2019).
44- Chin Teng Lin, Che Jui Chang, Bor Shyh Lin, Shao Hang Hung, Chih Feng Chao, and I. Jan Wang, "A real-time wireless brain-computer interface system for drowsiness detection." IEEE Transactions on Biomedical Circuits and Systems, Vol. 4pp. 214-22, (2010).
45- T. P. Nguyen, M. T. Chew, and S. Demidenko, "Eye tracking system to detect driver drowsiness." ICARA 2015 - Proceedings of the 2015 6th International Conference on Automation, Robotics and Applications, pp. 472-77, (2015).
46- David F. Dinges, M. Mallis Mallis, Greg Maislin, and John Walker Powell, "Evaluation of Techniques for Ocular Measurement as an Index of Fatigue and the Basis for Alertness Management." Security, (1998).
47- Siwar Chaabene, Bassem Bouaziz, Amal Boudaya, Anita Hökelmann, Achraf Ammar, and Lotfi Chaari, "Convolutional neural network for drowsiness detection using eeg signals." Sensors, Vol. 21pp. 1-19, (2021).
48- Edward A Wolpert, "A Manual of Standardized Terminology, Techniques and Scoring System for Sleep Stages of Human Subjects." Archives of General Psychiatry, Vol. 20pp. 246-47, (1969).
49- Lan-lan Chen, Yu Zhao, Jian Zhang, and Jun-zhong Zou, "Automatic detection of alertness/drowsiness from physiological signals using wavelet-based nonlinear features and machine learning." Expert Systems with Applications, Vol. 42pp. 7344-55, (2015).
50- Shayan Motamedi-Fakhr, Mohamed Moshrefi-Torbati, Martyn Hill, Catherine M Hill, and Paul R White, "Signal processing techniques applied to human sleep EEG signals—A review." Biomedical Signal Processing and Control, Vol. 10pp. 21-33, (2014).
51- Erik K St Louis et al., "Electroencephalography (EEG): An Introductory Text and Atlas of Normal and Abnormal Findings in Adults." Children, and Infants, (2016).
52- Balbir Singh and Hiroaki Wagatsuma, "A removal of eye movement and blink artifacts from EEG data using morphological component analysis." Computational and mathematical methods in medicine, Vol. 2017(2017).
53- Carrie A Joyce, Irina F Gorodnitsky, and Marta Kutas, "Automatic removal of eye movement and blink artifacts from EEG data using blind component separation." Psychophysiology, Vol. 41pp. 313-25, (2004).
54- J W Britton, "Hopp JLet al., authors; St. Louis EK, Frey LC, editors. Electroencephalography (EEG): An Introductory Text and Atlas of Normal and Abnormal Findings in Adults, Children, and Infants [Internet]. Chicago: American Epilepsy Society; 2016." ed.
55- Suresh D Muthukumaraswamy, "High-frequency brain activity and muscle artifacts in MEG/EEG: a review and recommendations." (in eng), Frontiers in Human Neuroscience, Vol. 7p. 138, (2013).
56- Theo Gasser, Jan C Schuller, and Ursula Schreiter Gasser, "Correction of muscle artefacts in the EEG power spectrum." Clinical Neurophysiology, Vol. 116pp. 2044-50, (2005).
57- Diego Antonio Rielo Selim R Benbadis, "EEG Artifacts." Medscape, (2019).
58- Joe-Air Jiang, Chih-Feng Chao, Ming-Jang Chiu, Ren-Guey Lee, Chwan-Lu Tseng, and Robert Lin, "An automatic analysis method for detecting and eliminating ECG artifacts in EEG." Computers in Biology and Medicine, Vol. 37pp. 1660-71, (2007).
59- Joanna Górecka and Przemysław Makiewicz, "The Dependence of Electrode Impedance on the Number of Performed EEG Examinations." (in eng), Sensors (Basel, Switzerland), Vol. 19p. 2608, (2019).
60- Abdulhamit Subasi, "Automatic recognition of alertness level from EEG by using neural network and wavelet coefficients." Expert Systems with Applications, Vol. 28pp. 701-11, (2005).
61- Hongtao Wang, Andrei Dragomir, Nida Itrat Abbasi, Junhua Li, Nitish V. Thakor, and Anastasios Bezerianos, "A novel real-time driving fatigue detection system based on wireless dry EEG." Cognitive Neurodynamics, Vol. 12pp. 365-76, (2018).
62- Jianliang Min, Ping Wang, and Jianfeng Hu, "Driver fatigue detection through multiple entropy fusion analysis in an EEG-based system." PLoS ONE, Vol. 12pp. 1-19, (2017).
63- Muhammad Awais, Nasreen Badruddin, and Micheal Drieberg, "A hybrid approach to detect driver drowsiness utilizing physiological signals to improve system performance and Wearability." Sensors (Switzerland), Vol. 17pp. 1-16, (2017).
64- O Dressler, G Schneider, G Stockmanns, and E F Kochs, "Awareness and the EEG power spectrum: analysis of frequencies." British Journal of Anaesthesia, Vol. 93pp. 806-09, (2004).
65- Hong J Eoh, Min K Chung, and Seong-Han Kim, "Electroencephalographic study of drowsiness in simulated driving with sleep deprivation." International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics, Vol. 35pp. 307-20, (2005).
66- Budi Thomas Jap, Sara Lal, Peter Fischer, and Evangelos Bekiaris, "Using EEG spectral components to assess algorithms for detecting fatigue." Expert Systems with Applications, Vol. 36pp. 2352-59, (2009).
67- Ahmed M. Dessouky, Taha E. Taha, Mohamed M. Dessouky, Ashraf A. Eltholth, Emadeldeen Hassan, and Fathi E. Abd El-Samie, "Non-parametric spectral estimation techniques for DNA sequence analysis and exon region prediction." Computers and Electrical Engineering, Vol. 73pp. 334-48, (2019).
68- M Aboy, J McNames, O W Marquez, R Hornero, T Thong, and B Goldstein, "Power spectral density estimation and tracking nonstationary pressure signals based on Kalman filtering." in The 26th Annual International Conference of the IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society Vol. 1, ed, (2004), pp. 156-59.
69- "Chapter 12 - Detection, Classification, and Estimation in the (t,f) Domain." in Time-Frequency Signal Analysis and Processing (Second Edition), Boualem Boashash, Ed., Second Edi ed. Oxford: Academic Press, (2016), pp. 693-743.
70- C. E. Shannon, "A Mathematical Theory of Communication." Bell System Technical Journal, Vol. 27pp. 623-56, (1948).
71- Jose Luis Rodríguez-Sotelo, Alejandro Osorio-Forero, Alejandro Jiménez-Rodríguez, David Cuesta-Frau, Eva Cirugeda-Roldán, and Diego Peluffo, "Automatic sleep stages classification using EEG entropy features and unsupervised pattern analysis techniques." Entropy, Vol. 16pp. 6573-89, (2014).
72- Sheng-Fu Liang, Chin-En Kuo, Yu-Han Hu, Yu-Hsiang Pan, and Yung-Hung Wang, "Automatic Stage Scoring of Single-Channel Sleep EEG by Using Multiscale Entropy and Autoregressive Models." IEEE Transactions on Instrumentation and Measurement, Vol. 61pp. 1649-57, (2012).
73- Peter Achermann, "EEG Analysis Applied to Sleep." Sleep Rochester, Vol. 26pp. 28-33, (2009).
74- Gianluca Borghini, Laura Astolfi, Giovanni Vecchiato, Donatella Mattia, and Fabio Babiloni, "Measuring neurophysiological signals in aircraft pilots and car drivers for the assessment of mental workload, fatigue and drowsiness." Neuroscience and Biobehavioral Reviews, Vol. 44pp. 58-75, (2014).
75- Gang Li et al., "The impact of mental fatigue on brain activity: A comparative study both in resting state and task state using EEG." BMC Neuroscience, Vol. 21pp. 1-9, (2020).
76- Qingjun Wang, Yibo Li, and Xueping Liu, "Analysis of Feature Fatigue EEG Signals Based on Wavelet Entropy." International Journal of Pattern Recognition and Artificial Intelligence, Vol. 32pp. 1-15, (2018).
77- S. M. Pincus and A. L. Goldberger, "Physiological time-series analysis: What does regularity quantify?" American Journal of Physiology - Heart and Circulatory Physiology, Vol. 266(1994).
78- Alfonso Delgado-Bonal and Alexander Marshak, "Approximate entropy and sample entropy: A comprehensive tutorial." Entropy, Vol. 21pp. 1-37, (2019).
79- J S Richman and J R Moorman, "Physiological time-series analysis using approximate entropy and sample entropy." (in eng), American journal of physiology. Heart and circulatory physiology, Vol. 278pp. H2039-49, (2000).
80- Weiting Chen, Zhizhong Wang, Hongbo Xie, and Wangxin Yu, "Characterization of Surface EMG Signal Based on Fuzzy Entropy." IEEE Transactions on Neural Systems and Rehabilitation Engineering, Vol. 15pp. 266-72, (2007).
81- Jianliang Min, Chen Xiong, Yonggang Zhang, and Ming Cai, "Driver fatigue detection based on prefrontal EEG using multi-entropy measures and hybrid model." Biomedical Signal Processing and Control, Vol. 69p. 102857, (2021).
82- Nikita Gurudath and H. Bryan Riley, "Drowsy driving detection by EEG analysis using Wavelet Transform and K-means clustering." Procedia Computer Science, Vol. 34pp. 400-09, (2014).
83- Noor Kamal Al-Qazzaz, Sawal Hamid Bin Mohd Ali, Siti Anom Ahmad, Mohd Shabiul Islam, and Javier Escudero, "Selection of Mother Wavelet Functions for Multi-Channel EEG Signal Analysis during a Working Memory Task." Sensors, Vol. 15pp. 29015-35, (2015).
84- Mehdi Hosseinzadeh, "4 - Robust control applications in biomedical engineering: Control of depth of hypnosis." in Control Applications for Biomedical Engineering Systems, Ahmad Taher Azar, Ed., ed: Academic Press, (2020), pp. 89-125.
85- Suganiya Murugan, Jerritta Selvaraj, and Arun Sahayadhas, "Detection and analysis: driver state with electrocardiogram (ECG)." Physical and Engineering Sciences in Medicine, Vol. 43pp. 525-37, (2020).
86- Sang-Ho Jo, Jin-Myung Kim, and Dong Kyoo Kim, "Heart Rate Change While Drowsy Driving." (in eng), Journal of Korean medical science, Vol. 34pp. e56-e56, (2019).
87- Difei Jing, Shuwei Zhang, and Zhongyin Guo, "Fatigue driving detection method for low-voltage and hypoxia plateau area: A physiological characteristic analysis approach." International Journal of Transportation Science and Technology, Vol. 9pp. 148-58, (2020).
88- Shahina Begum, "Intelligent driver monitoring systems based on physiological sensor signals: A review." in 16th International IEEE Conference on Intelligent Transportation Systems (ITSC 2013), ed, (2013), pp. 282-89.
89- Thomas Kundinger and Andreas Riener, "The Potential of Wrist-Worn Wearables for Driver Drowsiness Detection: A Feasibility Analysis." UMAP 2020 - Proceedings of the 28th ACM Conference on User Modeling, Adaptation and Personalization, pp. 117-25, (2020).
90- Thum Chia Chieh, Mohd. Marzuki Mustafa, Aini Hussain, Seyed Farshad Hendi, and Burhanuddin Yeop Majlis, "Development of vehicle driver drowsiness detection system using electrooculogram (EOG)." in 2005 1st International Conference on Computers, Communications, Signal Processing with Special Track on Biomedical Engineering, ed, (2005), pp. 165-68.
91- R. Schleicher, N. Galley, S. Briest, and L. Galley, "Blinks and saccades as indicators of fatigue in sleepiness warnings: Looking tired?" Ergonomics, Vol. 51pp. 982-1010, (2008).
92- Niels Galley, "Blink Parameter as indicator of drivers sleepiness." Nursing standard (Royal College of Nursing (Great Britain) : 1987), Vol. 23pp. 26-7, (2003).
93- Eun-Jung Sung, Byung-Chan Min, Seung-Chul Kim, and Chul-Jung Kim, "Effects of oxygen concentrations on driver fatigue during simulated driving." (in eng), Applied ergonomics, Vol. 36pp. 25-31, (2005).
94- Mahesh M. Bundele and Rahul Banerjee, "An SVM Classifier for Fatigue-Detection using Skin Conductance for Use in the BITS-Lifeguard Wearable Computing System Mahesh." Second International Conference on Emerging Trends in Engineering and Technology, ICETET-09, pp. 934-39, (2009).
95- Carlo J De Luca, "Myoelectrical manifestations of localized muscular fatigue in humans." Critical reviews in biomedical engineering, Vol. 11pp. 251-79, (1984).
96- Afraiz Tariq Satti, Jiyoun Kim, Eunsurk Yi, Hwi Young Cho, and Sungbo Cho, "Microneedle array electrode-based wearable emg system for detection of driver drowsiness through steering wheel grip." Sensors, Vol. 21pp. 1-14, (2021).
97- Anuva Chowdhury, Rajan Shankaran, Manolya Kavakli, and Md. Mokammel Haque, "Sensor Applications and Physiological Features in Drivers’ Drowsiness Detection: A Review." IEEE Sensors Journal, Vol. 18pp. 3055-67, (2018).
98- Mohammad Mahmoodi and Ali Nahvi, "Driver drowsiness detection based on classification of surface electromyography features in a driving simulator." Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part H: Journal of Engineering in Medicine, Vol. 233pp. 395-406, (2019).
99- Dong Wang, Peng Shen, Ting Wang, and Zhu Xiao, "Fatigue detection of vehicular driver through skin conductance, pulse oximetry and respiration: A random forest classifier." 2017 9th IEEE International Conference on Communication Software and Networks, ICCSN 2017, Vol. 2017-Januapp. 1162-66, (2017).
100- Wolfram Boucsein, "Electrodermal activity." (2012).
101- Johanna Wörle, Barbara Metz, Christian Thiele, and Gert Weller, "Detecting sleep in drivers during highly automated driving: The potential of physiological parameters." IET Intelligent Transport Systems, Vol. 13pp. 1241-48, (2019).
102- Kitsuchart Pasupa and Wisuwat Sunhem, "A comparison between shallow and deep architecture classifiers on small dataset." in 2016 8th International Conference on Information Technology and Electrical Engineering (ICITEE), ed: IEEE, (2016), pp. 1-6.
103- Xu-Cheng Yin, Chun Yang, Wei-Yi Pei, and Hong-Wei Hao, "Shallow classification or deep learning: An experimental study." in 2014 22nd International Conference on Pattern Recognition, ed: IEEE, (2014), pp. 1904-09.
104- Alaa Tharwat, Tarek Gaber, Abdelhameed Ibrahim, and Aboul Ella Hassanien, "Linear discriminant analysis: A detailed tutorial." AI Communications, Vol. 30pp. 169-90, (2017).
105- D Garrett, D A Peterson, C W Anderson, and M H Thaut, "Comparison of linear, nonlinear, and feature selection methods for EEG signal classification." IEEE Transactions on Neural Systems and Rehabilitation Engineering, Vol. 11pp. 141-44, (2003).
106- Prima Dewi Purnamasari, Pratiwi Yustiana, Anak Agung Putri Ratna, and Dodi Sudiana, "Mobile EEG Based Drowsiness Detection using K-Nearest Neighbor." 2019 IEEE 10th International Conference on Awareness Science and Technology, iCAST 2019 - Proceedings, pp. 1-5, (2019).
107- Himani Sharma and Sunil Kumar, "A Survey on Decision Tree Algorithms of Classification in Data Mining." International Journal of Science and Research (IJSR), Vol. 5pp. 2094-97, (2016).
108- Ludmila Kuncheva, "Fuzzy classifier design." Vol. 49(2000).
109- David J Livingstone, "Artificial neural networks: methods and applications." (2008).
110- Zhongke Gao et al., "EEG-Based Spatio-Temporal Convolutional Neural Network for Driver Fatigue Evaluation." IEEE transactions on neural networks and learning systems, Vol. 30pp. 2755-63, (2019).
111- Sibsambhu Kar, Mayank Bhagat, and Aurobinda Routray, "EEG signal analysis for the assessment and quantification of driver's fatigue." Transportation Research Part F: Traffic Psychology and Behaviour, Vol. 13pp. 297-306, (2010).
112- Tiago da Silveira, Alice de Jesus Kozakevicius, and Cesar Ramos Rodrigues, "Drowsiness detection for single channel EEG by DWT best m-term approximation." Revista Brasileira de Engenharia Biomedica, Vol. 31pp. 107-15, (2015).
113- Yuliang Ma et al., "Driving fatigue detection from EEG using a modified PCANet method." Computational Intelligence and Neuroscience, Vol. 2019(2019).
114- Yuqi Cui, Yifan Xu, and Dongrui Wu, "EEG-Based Driver Drowsiness Estimation Using Feature Weighted Episodic Training." IEEE Transactions on Neural Systems and Rehabilitation Engineering, Vol. 27pp. 2263-73, (2019).
115- Haowen Luo, Taorong Qiu, Chao Liu, and Peifan Huang, "Research on fatigue driving detection using forehead EEG based on adaptive multi-scale entropy." Biomedical Signal Processing and Control, Vol. 51pp. 50-58, (2019).
116- Venkata Phanikrishna B and Suchismitha Chinara, "Automatic classification methods for detecting drowsiness using wavelet packet transform extracted time-domain features from single-channel EEG signal." Journal of Neuroscience Methods, Vol. 347p. 108927, (2021).
117- Mervyn V.M. Yeo, Xiaoping Li, Kaiquan Shen, and Einar P.V. Wilder-Smith, "Can SVM be used for automatic EEG detection of drowsiness during car driving?" Safety Science, Vol. 47pp. 115-24, (2009).
118- Yuxuan Yang, Zhongke Gao, Yanli Li, Qing Cai, Norbert Marwan, and Jurgen Kurths, "A Complex Network-Based Broad Learning System for Detecting Driver Fatigue From EEG Signals." IEEE Transactions on Systems, Man, and Cybernetics: Systems, pp. 1-9, (2019).
119- Christos Papadelis et al., "Indicators of Sleepiness in an ambulatory EEG study of night driving." Annual International Conference of the IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology - Proceedings, pp. 6201-04, (2006).
120- Zhendong Mu, Jianfeng Hu, and Jinghai Yin, "Driving Fatigue Detecting Based on EEG Signals of Forehead Area." International Journal of Pattern Recognition and Artificial Intelligence, Vol. 31pp. 1-12, (2017).
121- Yuliang Ma et al., "Driving drowsiness detection with EEG using a modified hierarchical extreme learning machine algorithm with particle swarm optimization: A pilot study." Electronics (Switzerland), Vol. 9(2020).
122- Rifai Chai et al., "Driver Fatigue Classification with Independent Component by Entropy Rate Bound Minimization Analysis in an EEG-Based System." IEEE Journal of Biomedical and Health Informatics, Vol. 21pp. 715-24, (2017).
123- Hong Zeng, Chen Yang, Guojun Dai, Feiwei Qin, Jianhai Zhang, and Wanzeng Kong, "EEG classification of driver mental states by deep learning." Cognitive Neurodynamics, Vol. 12pp. 597-606, (2018).
124- Zahra Mardi, Seyedeh Naghmeh Ashtiani, and Mohammad Mikaili, "EEG-based drowsiness detection for safe driving using chaotic features and statistical tests." Journal of Medical Signals and Sensors, Vol. 1pp. 130-37, (2011).
125- Chunlin Zhao, Chongxun Zheng, Min Zhao, Yaling Tu, and Jianping Liu, "Multivariate autoregressive models and kernel learning algorithms for classifying driving mental fatigue based on electroencephalographic." Expert Systems with Applications, Vol. 38pp. 1859-65, (2011).
126- Pranesh Krishnan, Mohamed Rizon, Sazali Yaacob, and Annapoorni Pranesh Krishnan, "EEG based drowsiness detection using relative band power and short time fourier transform." Proceedings of International Conference on Artificial Life and Robotics, Vol. 2020pp. 323-27, (2020).
127- Mikito Ogino and Yasue Mitsukura, "Portable drowsiness detection through use of a prefrontal single-channel electroencephalogram." Sensors (Switzerland), Vol. 18pp. 1-19, (2018).
128- Fnu Rohit, Vinod Kulathumani, Rahul Kavi, Ibrahim Elwarfalli, Vlad Kecojevic, and Ashish Nimbarte, "Real-time drowsiness detection using wearable, lightweight brain sensing headbands." IET Intelligent Transport Systems, Vol. 11pp. 255-63, (2017).
129- Mohammad A. Almogbel, Anh H. Dang, and Wataru Kameyama, "Cognitive Workload Detection from Raw EEG-Signals of Vehicle Driver using Deep Learning." International Conference on Advanced Communication Technology, ICACT, Vol. 2019-Februpp. 1167-72, (2019).
130- Topo Suprihadi and Kanisius Karyono, "DROWTION: Driver drowsiness detection software using MINDWAVE." in 2014 International Conference on Industrial Automation, Information and Communications Technology, ed: IEEE, (2014), pp. 141-44.
131- A. S. Abdel-Rahman, A. F. Seddik, and D. M. Shawky, "An affordable approach for detecting drivers' drowsiness using EEG signal analysis." 2015 International Conference on Advances in Computing, Communications and Informatics, ICACCI 2015, pp. 1326-32, (2015).
132- Bryan Van Hal, Samhita Rhodes, Bruce Dunne, and Robert Bossemeyer, "Low-cost EEG-based sleep detection." in 2014 36th Annual International Conference of the IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society, ed: IEEE, (2014), pp. 4571-74.
133- Prabha C Nissimagoudar and Anilkumar V Nandi, "Precision enhancement of driver assistant system using eeg based driver consciousness analysis & classification." in Computational Network Application Tools for Performance Management, ed: Springer, (2020), pp. 247-57.
134- A Pomer-Escher, R Tello, J Castillo, and T Bastos-Filho, "Analysis of mental fatigue in motor imagery and emotional stimulation based on EEG." in XXIV Congresso Brasileiro de Engenharia Biomedica-CBEB, ed, (2014).
135- Mejdi Ben Dkhil, Ali Wali, and Adel M Alimi, "Drowsy driver detection by EEG analysis using Fast Fourier Transform." in 2015 15th International Conference on Intelligent Systems Design and Applications (ISDA), ed: IEEE, (2015), pp. 313-18.
136- Vipin Bakshi, "Towards Practical Driver Cognitive Workload Monitoring via Electroencephalography." ed, (2018).
137- Fei Wang, Ji Lin, Wenzhe Wang, and Haiming Wang, "EEG-based mental fatigue assessment during driving by using sample entropy and rhythm energy." 2015 IEEE International Conference on Cyber Technology in Automation, Control and Intelligent Systems, IEEE-CYBER 2015, pp. 1906-11, (2015).
138- Jichi Chen, Hong Wang, Qiaoxiu Wang, and Chengcheng Hua, "Exploring the fatigue affecting electroencephalography based functional brain networks during real driving in young males." Neuropsychologia, Vol. 129pp. 200-11, (2019).
139- Brilian T. Nugraha, Riyanarto Sarno, Dimas Anton Asfani, Tomohiko Igasaki, and M. Nadzeri Munawar, "Classification of driver fatigue state based on EEG using Emotiv EPOC+." Journal of Theoretical and Applied Information Technology, Vol. 86pp. 347-59, (2016).
140- Dariusz Sawicki, Agnieszka Wolska, Przemysław Rosłon, and Szymon Ordysiński, "New EEG measure of the alertness analyzed by Emotiv EPOC in a real working environment." NEUROTECHNIX 2016 - Proceedings of the 4th International Congress on Neurotechnology, Electronics and Informatics, pp. 35-42, (2016).
141- Thi Tram Anh Pham, Thi Diem Hang Nguyen, Quoc Khai Le, and Quang Linh Huynh, "Application of portable EEG device in detection and classification drowsiness by support vector machine." in International Conference on the Development of Biomedical Engineering in Vietnam, ed: Springer, (2018), pp. 521-26.
142- S S Poorna, V V Arsha, P T A Aparna, Parvathy Gopal, and G J Nair, "Drowsiness detection for safe driving using PCA EEG signals." in Progress in computing, analytics and networking, ed: Springer, (2018), pp. 419-28.
143- Osmalina Nur Rahma and Akif Rahmatillah, "Drowsiness analysis using common spatial pattern and extreme learning machine based on electroencephalogram signal." Journal of medical signals and sensors, Vol. 9p. 130, (2019).
144- Theerat Saichoo and Poonpong Boonbrahm, "Brain Computer Interface for Real-Time Driver Drowsiness Detection." Thai Journal of Physics, Vol. 36pp. 1-8, (2019).
145- Beatriz Campos Raposo Medeiros Araújo, "Drowsiness Detection Using a Headband and Artificial Neural Networks." ed: Universidade de Coimbra, (2019).
146- Heng Li, Di Wang, Jiayu Chen, Xiaochun Luo, Jue Li, and Xuejiao Xing, "Pre-service fatigue screening for construction workers through wearable EEG-based signal spectral analysis." Automation in Construction, Vol. 106p. 102851, (2019).
147- Asim Javed, Muhammad Umair Arshad, Ehtesham Saeed, and Noman Naseer, "Real-time Drowsiness Detection and Emergency Parking using EEG." (2021).
148- Muhammad Azam, Derek Jacoby, and Yvonne Coady, "Classification of Fatigue in Consumer-grade EEG Using Entropies as Features."
149- Jerone Dunbar, Juan E Gilbert, and Ben Lewis, "Exploring differences between self-report and electrophysiological indices of drowsy driving: A usability examination of a personal brain-computer interface device." Journal of Safety Research, Vol. 74pp. 27-34, (2020).
150- Ruyi Foong, Kai Keng Ang, Zhuo Zhang, and Chai Quek, "An iterative cross-subject negative-unlabeled learning algorithm for quantifying passive fatigue." Journal of neural engineering, Vol. 16p. 56013, (2019).
151- Aqsa Mehreen, Syed Muhammad Anwar, Muhammad Haseeb, Muhammad Majid, and Muhammad Obaid Ullah, "A hybrid scheme for drowsiness detection using wearable sensors." IEEE Sensors Journal, Vol. 19pp. 5119-26, (2019).
152- Chee-Keong Alfred Lim, Wai Chong Chia, and Siew Wen Chin, "A mobile driver safety system: Analysis of single-channel EEG on drowsiness detection." in 2014 International Conference on Computational Science and Technology (ICCST), ed, (2014), pp. 1-5.
153- Hamzah S. Alzu'Bi, Waleed Al-Nuaimy, and Nayel S. Al-Zubi, "EEG-based driver fatigue detection." Proceedings - 2013 6th International Conference on Developments in eSystems Engineering, DeSE 2013, pp. 111-14, (2013).
154- Thien Nguyen, Sangtae Ahn, Hyojung Jang, Sung Chan Jun, and Jae Gwan Kim, "Utilization of a combined EEG/NIRS system to predict driver drowsiness." Scientific Reports, Vol. 7pp. 1-10, (2017).
155- Nhat Pham et al., "WAKE: A behind-the-ear wearable system for microsleep detection." MobiSys 2020 - Proceedings of the 18th International Conference on Mobile Systems, Applications, and Services, pp. 404-18, (2020).
156- M Jagannath and Venkatesh Balasubramanian, "Assessment of early onset of driver fatigue using multimodal fatigue measures in a static simulator." Applied ergonomics, Vol. 45pp. 1140-47, (2014).
157- Chunxiao Chen, Kun Li, Qiuyi Wu, Haowen Wang, Zhiyu Qian, and Gail Sudlow, "EEG-based detection and evaluation of fatigue caused by watching 3DTV." Displays, Vol. 34pp. 81-88, (2013).
158- Michael Simon et al., "Eeg alpha spindle measures as indicators of driver fatigue under real traffic conditions." Clinical Neurophysiology, Vol. 122pp. 1168-78, (2011).
159- Malik T.R. Peiris, Paul R. Davidson, Philip J. Bones, and Richard D. Jones, "Detection of lapses in responsiveness from the EEG." Journal of Neural Engineering, Vol. 8(2011).
160- Mehmet Akin, Muhammed B Kurt, Necmettin Sezgin, and Muhittin Bayram, "Estimating vigilance level by using EEG and EMG signals." Neural Computing and Applications, Vol. 17pp. 227-36, (2008).
161- Gang Li and Wan Young Chung, "A context-aware EEG headset system for early detection of driver drowsiness." Sensors (Switzerland), Vol. 15pp. 20873-93, (2015).
162- Sazali Yaacob, Nur Afrina Izzati Affandi, Pranesh Krishnan, Amir Rasyadan, Muhyi Yaakop, and Firdaus Mohamed, "Drowsiness detection using EEG and ECG signals." IEEE International Conference on Artificial Intelligence in Engineering and Technology, IICAIET 2020, pp. 2-6, (2020).
163- Wei Long Zheng and Bao Liang Lu, "A multimodal approach to estimating vigilance using EEG and forehead EOG." Journal of Neural Engineering, Vol. 14(2017).
164- Hongtao Wang, Cong Wu, Ting Li, Yuebang He, Peng Chen, and Anastasios Bezerianos, "Driving Fatigue Classification Based on Fusion Entropy Analysis Combining EOG and EEG." IEEE Access, Vol. 7pp. 61975-86, (2019).
165- Shaibal Barua, Mobyen Uddin Ahmed, Christer Ahlström, and Shahina Begum, "Automatic driver sleepiness detection using EEG, EOG and contextual information." Expert Systems with Applications, Vol. 115pp. 121-35, (2019).
166- Saroj K.L. Lal, Ashley Craig, Peter Boord, Les Kirkup, and Hung Nguyen, "Development of an algorithm for an EEG-based driver fatigue countermeasure." Journal of Safety Research, Vol. 34pp. 321-28, (2003).
167- Yingying Jiao, Yini Deng, Yun Luo, and Bao Liang Lu, "Driver sleepiness detection from EEG and EOG signals using GAN and LSTM networks." Neurocomputing, Vol. 408pp. 100-11, (2020).
168- Aleksandra Vuckovic, Vlada Radivojevic, Andrew C.N. Chen, and Dejan Popovic, "Automatic recognition of alertness and drowsiness from EEG by an artificial neural network." Medical Engineering and Physics, Vol. 24pp. 349-60, (2002).
169- Xue Qin Huo, Wei Long Zheng, and Bao Liang Lu, "Driving fatigue detection with fusion of EEG and forehead EOG." Proceedings of the International Joint Conference on Neural Networks, Vol. 2016-Octobpp. 897-904, (2016).
170- Faramarz Gharagozlou et al., "Detecting driver mental fatigue based on EEG alpha power changes during simulated driving." Iranian Journal of Public Health, Vol. 44pp. 1693-700, (2015).
171- Boon Giin Lee, Boon Leng Lee, and Wan Young Chung, "Mobile healthcare for automatic driving sleep-onset detection using wavelet-based EEG and respiration signals." Sensors (Switzerland), Vol. 14pp. 17915-36, (2014).
172- Kushaba, "Driver Drowsiness Classif cation Using Fuzzy Wavelet Packet Based Feature Extraction Algorithm." (2011).
173- Sangtae Ahn, Thien Nguyen, Hyojung Jang, Jae G. Kim, and Sung C. Jun, "Exploring neuro-physiological correlates of drivers’ mental fatigue caused by sleep deprivation using simultaneous EEG, ECG, and fNIRS data." Frontiers in Human Neuroscience, Vol. 10pp. 1-14, (2016).
174- Chin Teng Lin, Ruei Cheng Wu, Tzyy Ping Jung, Sheng Fu Liang, and Teng Yi Huang, "Estimating driving performance based on EEG spectrum analysis." Eurasip Journal on Applied Signal Processing, Vol. 2005pp. 3165-74, (2005).
175- Boon Leng Lee, Boon Giin Lee, and Wan Young Chung, "Standalone Wearable Driver Drowsiness Detection System in a Smartwatch." IEEE Sensors Journal, Vol. 16pp. 5444-51, (2016).
176- Fajar Manghayu Nuswantoro, Amang Sudarsono, and Tri Budi Santoso, "Abnormal driving detection based on accelerometer and gyroscope sensor on smartphone using artificial neural network (ann) algorithm." IES 2020 - International Electronics Symposium: The Role of Autonomous and Intelligent Systems for Human Life and Comfort, pp. 356-63, (2020).
Files
IssueVol 9 No 4 (2022) QRcode
SectionLiterature (Narrative) Review(s)
DOI https://doi.org/10.18502/fbt.v9i4.10426
Keywords
Drowsiness Detection Fatigue Electroencephalography Features Commercial Electroencephalography Headsets Hybrid Systems

Rights and permissions
Creative Commons License This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
How to Cite
1.
Sheibani Asl N, Baghdadi G, Ebrahimian S, Javaher Haghighi S. Toward Applicable EEG-Based Drowsiness Detection Systems: A Review. Frontiers Biomed Technol. 2022;9(4):323-350.